‘Variant of concern’ is not a descriptor of our feelings, but one of the working names of B.1.1.7. When a new, different strain is found such as in the UK, South Africa or today in Japan, scientists ask three critical questions. (a) Is the variant more transmissible? (b) is it more deadly, more severe? (c) Can it bypass vaccines?
*****
On transmissibility, there is no doubt. Scientists
initially estimated it was 70% more transmissible, but the latest modelling
puts it at 56% higher. When R-zero, the reproductive number is 1, an infected
person on average passes it to one other person. The pandemic grows when R0 is
greater than one, declines when below 1. British researchers estimate that during
lockdown, coronaviruses other than the B.1.1.7 variant have R0 at 0.95.
The reproductive number of B.1.1.7 is 1.45. Genetic sequence traced it
back to 20 September in Kent, another case in Greater London the following day.
By now, 45 countries have confirmed existence of cases with this
variant.
One theory for the rapid spread is that the variant
has a heightened viral load, a higher concentration of the virus in the upper
respiratory tract. Until now, this theory is not backed by credible data.
*****
Scientists have said B.1.17 spreads faster, but it is
neither more deadly, more damaging or more severe. Presenting this fact as good
news is misleading for two reasons.
First, there is a clearly established sequence: cases –
hospitalizations – deaths. The more the cases, more patients get admitted and a
certain proportion dies. By spreading faster, the new variant infects some
vulnerable people who would be safe in a less transmissible variant. As ICU
beds reach capacity and the health care system gets overwhelmed, non-covid
patients are unable to treat their ailments or get operated. That increases the
toll. The excess mortality tracker shows the total pandemic-related casualty
figures.
Second, mathematically a more deadly virus does less
damage than a more transmissible virus. Professor Kucharski takes a realistic scenario,
where the reproduction rate is 1.1, fatality risk 0.8% and 10,000 active
infections. With those numbers, we expect 129 deaths in a month. If fatality
rate increases by 50%, that leads to 193 deaths. On the other hand, a 50%
increase in transmissibility causes a shocking 978 deaths in just one month.
A more deadly variant can be tragic for an infected individual,
that person may not survive. But the rapidly spreading variant is tragic for society.
By spreading faster, it manages to kill far more people. (This is because a
small % of a large number can be much bigger than a big % of a small number.)
*****
The third question is if it can bypass vaccination.
Here we have some truly good news. The consensus among
the scientists is that the vaccines will work against this variant. One virologist
compares the vaccine to a thousand big guns pointed at the virus. Even with the
23 mutations, it is not easy for the virus to find a genetic solution to combat
all the antibody specificities and the overall immune response.
Viruses like influenza amass mutations relatively
quickly. But others, such as the measles virus, are stable over a long time.
Even the influenza virus needs five to seven years to collect enough mutations
to escape immune recognition.
Despite the growing spread across the world, the covid
virus can still attack armies of uninfected people. That is why it has no reason
currently to do anything spectacular. At will, it is able to find new hosts for
it to enter and multiply. So, it is felt that the coronavirus is not yet
interested in developing anti-vaccine weapons of its own. However, once enough
people are vaccinated, the virus may evolve into an incarnation that will bypass
the vaccine.
*****
In short, B.1.1.7 spreads faster. Though not
inherently more deadly, its impact on the countries and the world is more
deadly because of the faster spread. Currently, it is understood that vaccines
can protect us against this variant. That comfort is available until such point
when there are too many people vaccinated for the coronavirus’s comfort.
Ravi
Still frightening in London.
ReplyDelete