In
December 2004, my British friend Lisa came to Bombay to visit me. Lisa and I
are friends for more than thirty years. She is a lesbian and I am very
straight. That makes it an enviable platonic friendship. On that trip, Lisa had
come with a girl older than her. Don’t know if they were mere friends or more,
but it was none of my business.
Bombay
is not a touristy place. Once the two British girls saw the Gateway of India,
the Gothic architecture in South Bombay built by their own ancestors, and
refused to visit the Elephanta Island, because of the Tsunami which had
happened that week, not much remained to be seen. From the day of arrival, they
had expressed interest in Bollywood. I had to disappoint them by saying
there is no such place as Bollywood. Hollywood exists, but not Bollywood. The
best thing that can be done is to watch a Bollywood movie.
Bollywood
movies are fairy tales for adults. Protagonists must be good looking, the
leading lady Miss Universe if possible. Villains must look and act nasty. Every
fifteen minutes or so, the storyline freezes, and everyone starts dancing. The
leads (called the hero and the heroine) take carefully choreographed bollywood
steps, and behind them are hundreds of dancers creating the Indian corps de
ballet. The dances are extremely colorful, rhythms invigorating, sets
appealing and tunes catchy. The seven or eight songs in the film may have
nothing to do with the plot, but they offer a welcome relief to those who wish
to buy popcorns, visit restrooms or answer missed calls. In effect, every
Bollywood film is a musical. I thought Lisa and her friend would enjoy that
part much. Also I won’t need to translate anything when the songs are on.
I checked
with my Indian friends. They recommended Dhoom, a blockbuster film of
that year. It was a nonstop action thriller, with seven or eight songs. An
ideal film for foreigners wishing to get a taste of Bollywood. Dhoom had the
famous Dhoom machale number, which I was obliged to listen to every morning at
my gym.
In
2004, we couldn’t yet book movie tickets on internet. I checked the Dhoom
timings in the newspaper. Lisa, her friend and I took a taxi to a nearby
multi-screen cinema. We waited patiently in the queue for tickets, anxiously
looking at the watch. I like to watch the ads before the movies.
“Three
tickets for Dhoom, please.” I said at the counter.
“Dhoom?
That’s house-full.” The man, whose head was the only visible part, said. I thought
he frowned to suggest people just can’t walk in ten minutes before Dhoom and
expect to get tickets.
“Look,
I have my friends from abroad here. They wish to see a Bollywood movie. If
Dhoom is not possible… do you have tickets… for…. Hulchul?” That was another
recommendation from friends. This one had Kareena Kapoor, and six songs.
“No
tickets for Hulchul either.” The man said. By now the queue behind us was
getting restless. Indians respect foreigners, but only up to a certain point.
The ticket seller gave me the names of the remaining films.
“I have
tickets for Raincoat. Raincoat has Aishwarya Rai.”
Raincoat
was a good English title. Maybe the film has lots of English dialogue, I
thought. And Aishwarya Rai was a Miss
World. I briefly told Lisa what the options were, and bought tickets for
Raincoat.
By the
time we reached our seats, we had missed the ads and trailers. Suddenly Raincoat,
the feature of the day, started. The film begins with Ajay Devgan, the lead
actor, coming to Calcutta from a smaller town. He has lost his job. He meets
the woman (Aishwarya Rai) he was engaged to many years ago. She is now married.
For the first ten minutes, maybe twenty, the two protagonists are in a
depressing-looking room, just talking to each other. Films connected to Bengal
are generally depressing. This one had no music, no songs. The two protagonists
were speaking in chaste Hindi. Of course, no subtitles.
In the
darkness, I turned to Lisa and whispered, “I am so sorry. The title Raincoat
was misleading. They are talking in pure Hindi. And no songs, no dances. It
seems unlikely there will be any. Please tell me when you wish to leave, and we
will leave. Sorry.”
I
waited for five minutes. I had lost interest in the film. As soon as Lisa gave
a signal, we would all leave. Lisa was still focused on the screen. I kept
taking my eyes off the screen and looking at her for a sign.
“We can
leave when you wish.” I said once again.
“No,
no. It’s fine. I think we will guess the storyline. In any case, I can just
keep watching her endlessly.”
Well,
if Lisa is happy looking at Aishwarya for two hours, why should I hurry? Or
worry? Gradually, I got over my guilt, and began to get involved in the movie.
At
interval, three of us came out.
“Once
again, so sorry for bringing you to this film. I want you to know this film is
exactly what Bollywood films are not. If I wanted you to understand how
Bollywood films are not made, I would have selected this film. It must be a
torture for you to sit through the hour without understanding a word. I can
give you….”
“On the
contrary…” Lisa said. “We understood the whole story. The visual medium doesn’t
need words. And these are good actors. We are enjoying the film, don’t worry.”
Wow, I
thought. I had always admired Lisa’s intelligence. To appreciate a film without
knowing a word in that language was remarkable.
“She is
a prostitute.” Lisa began. “And he is a drug-dealer. Both are unhappy about
their professions. That unhappiness has brought them together. They are
discussing how both of them can escape with each other’s help….”
Lisa
went on and on. Giving me minute details of the storyline. I didn’t interrupt
her. My initial thought was to give the English girls the gist of the story,
until interval. Since I had not seen the film before, I had no idea what would
happen in the second half. But if I could tell Lisa the story till interval,
that would make her life easier. When Lisa told me the story, I changed my
mind.
The
English girls had invented a story. Just by watching what was happening on the
screen. They could continue in the same vein till the end of the film.
I said
nothing. Of course, she was not a prostitute, neither was he a drug-dealer.
Lisa’s was a western perspective on the images she had seen. Her entire
storyline, though interesting, had absolutely nothing to do with the real
storyline. But who was I to disrupt her creativity? Would the real story be as
enjoyable for them as the fiction in their mind?
We
re-entered the auditorium to watch the movie. On that day, Lisa and I watched
the same movie with two different storylines.
Ravi
I don't know how to put emoji of shocked face here. Omg, what impression those girls might have carried about bollywood?
ReplyDeleteThis is a great story Ravi. Greetings from Poland where true Bollywood movies were shot.
ReplyDelete